Hello dear
Welcome to Blue Spring Pizza
Blue Spring Pizza, located in Orange City, FL, stands out for its delicious New York-style pizza and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Known for its impressive portion sizes and fair pricing, this eatery has garnered rave reviews from patrons who praise the thin crust and flavorful sauce. The menu boasts a variety of tasty appetizers, including garlic knots, calamari, and fried pickles, all perfect for sharing or savoring solo. With friendly staff who ensure excellent service, Blue Spring Pizza has quickly become a favorite for families and pizza lovers alike, promising a delightful dining experience worth returning to again and again.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
GARLIC KNOTS (6)
GARLIC KNOTS (6) W/ CHEESE
GARLIC BREAD
GARLIC BREAD W/ CHEESE
About
Blue Spring Pizza
Welcome to Blue Spring Pizza, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Orange City, Florida. Located at 501 N Volusia Ave, this charming eatery has quickly made a name for itself as a go-to spot for those craving delicious, New York-style pizza and more. From the moment you step through the door, the warm and welcoming atmosphere, coupled with friendly service, makes you feel right at home.
At Blue Spring Pizza, the menu boasts a range of appetizing offerings that cater to every palate. Begin your meal with mouthwatering Garlic Knots or crispy Onion Rings, sure to whet your appetite. If you’re in the mood for something cheesy, the Garlic Knots with Cheese or Mozzarella Sticks are a perfect choice. For the more adventurous, the Fried Pickles paired with ranch dressing are a must-try, as echoed by patrons who rave about their addictive flavor.
But let’s dive into the star of the show: the pizza. Guests have consistently praised Blue Spring Pizza for its authentic New York-style slices, which are generously topped with flavorful sauce and gooey cheese. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a crowd favorite, delighting taste buds with its juicy toppings and spiced perfection. Customer reviews reflect a shared sentiment of tastiness, with one fan stating that the pizza compares favorably to their favorite New York establishments.
For those who enjoy wings, the experience here does not disappoint. Deep-fried to crispy perfection and tossed in savory sauces, the wings come highly recommended. One satisfied family even claimed they preferred Blue Spring’s rendition of Carbonara to that from a well-known chain—an impressive testament to the quality of their dishes!
With fair pricing and generous portion sizes, Blue Spring Pizza stands out as an excellent dining option for families and food enthusiasts alike. Whether you’re stopping by after a day at the springs or making a special trip, their warm service and delightful food promise a satisfying experience. Come for the pizza, stay for the ambiance, and leave with a newfound favorite restaurant that you’ll be eager to return to time and time again.
To contact them or to place an order, just dial +1 386-218-4319. Your journey of deliciousness at Blue Spring Pizza awaits!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ First time stopping in after a cold visit at the springs. I was impressed with the food. Prices are fair, portions are large and staff is very friendly. Pizza was actually delicious. It’s hard to find pizza close to New York style and taste, and I was pleasantly surprised at how close this tasted and felt like New York pizza. Thin crust, good sauce and good cheese. Slices were larger than a New York style but good, and I actually prefer the bigger slices. Will definitely stop in again when in the area, maybe even go out of the way to come here ”
“ My family and I really liked this place. Kids test. My boy thought the carbonera here was better than the one served at the Cheesecake Factory! That's a statement. Staff is really nice. We also tried the wings. They make it right! Deep fried and sauce after. Great pizza as well! Wife tends to always critique every restaurant we go to with several suggestions for improvement but did not have any for this place. ”
“ Delicious Pizza Kim was an awesome server. She was solo and handled it all! ”
“ Their wings , Buffalo pizza and fried pickles are super tasty for the wings I mixed mild buffalo and garlic Parmesan and let me tell you how juicyyyy they were !!!! And the pickles are one of my fav appetizers to eat ! If you love buffalo chicken pizza then this definitely is the spot to try it ! ”
“ We seriously love this place!! Tasty food, fast excellent service, quaint family friendly atmosphere. Tight parking but otherwise such a wonderful place top will definitely be coming back ”
“ In case you were wondering.. definitely did not disappoint! Alfredo was so creamy with lots of sauce. Better than Olive Garden!! Noodles were cooked perfectly and chicken was seasoned so well and tender! My kids loved the pizza, but luckily there was enough Alfredo to share because they all wanted some lol The garlic knots are really good too! Pizza sauce is on the sweet side, which we like. Will definitely be eating here again! ”
“ Just came back from New York City l saw the sign pizza by the slice took a chance hit the jackpot if you live in Orange city this is the place to get a real slice of pizza thank you ladies served up hot ice cold Pepsi. I’m going to enjoy my trip back to Jacksonville. Wish we had a this there!! ”
“ This place is great. It looks small, however pretty big when you get inside. Limited parking, well lit and easy accessibility Easy menu and meduim priced. Lots of seating and good atmosphere Food is huge and extremely tasty. Great staff and service. Indoor and outdoor seating. Kid friendly Highly recommended ”